PORTLAND Portland Mayor Charlie Hales has revoked a Bureau of Development Services permit for a new apartment complex on Southeast Division that has been the target of some unhappy neighbors.
The general reason for the controversy insufficient parking. But how this got to be a problem on Division Street typifies Portland, a place proud of its plastic shopping bag ban and global warming action plan but still struggling with how to grow while staying green.
A developer, Dennis Sackhoff, last year demolished what had been the city's landmark lesbian bar and started construction on a four-story, 81-unit apartment building that will include scores of bicycle racks but not one parking space for automobiles.
It's one of about 30 parking-free apartment buildings that have been recently completed or are in some stage of development in the city, mostly in the cozy neighborhoods on the east side, across the Willamette River from downtown.
The city strives for fairness and doesn t always get it on the first shot, Hales said Thursday. That s why I m taking this action. The city did a disservice by not providing clear answers to the neighbors over the last month. The neighbors acted in good faith.
The Richmond Neighbors for Responsible Growth said Friday that Hales' decision will allow BDS to undertake appropriate review following the decision.
Initially, BDS was accused of working in secrecy and preventing community input during the permitting process. At stake was the question of a land use permit that had possibly been wrongfully issued, the group said.
Mayor Hales demonstrated a combination of leadership, straightforwardness and a commitment to fair play in his handling of this issue. We are also deeply appreciative of the thoughtful and committed effort of the other city commissioners who worked so hard to address community concerns in response to the surprise decision which the Mayor has now rescinded.
The group also expressed their wishes to the developer for the opportunity for a successful project. We renew our longstanding offer to work together with the developer toward such a solution.
The council will hear recommendations on April 4.
Though Portlanders are remarkably united when it comes to protecting the environment, the property has provoked an unexpected backlash against the city's progressive approach to housing its burgeoning population.
Developers such as Sackhoff are capitalizing on one of the nation's tightest rental markets while following Portland zoning rules that require them to provide parking for bicycles but not cars.
The people who already live in these neighborhoods worry about increased traffic and an inability to find parking in front of their places. And though the apartments are intended for those with a bicycle-first mentality, most of the new tenants are not choosing a car-free existence.
The developer says he is trying to give Portland what it says it wants, but in reality, Portland wants it both ways, said John Golden, a high school teacher trying to stop, or at least reduce, the size of another four-story apartment building in the works near his NE Portland house.
Sackhoff, who declined to be interviewed, is the developer on that project, too.
Portland has carefully charted a course that has made it one of the most environmentally friendly urban areas in the country. Its strategic planning emphasizes the use of alternative forms of transportation, such as light-rail, a streetcar, skateboarding and bicycles. A major bridge is under construction across the Willamette that will be off-limits to cars.
The zoning rules and planning goals that spawned the surge in parking-free apartments were meant to discourage people from owning cars and also entice developers to build apartments closer to downtown, limiting the type of farmland-devouring sprawl seen in many U.S. metropolitan areas.
Hales was on the City Council in 2002 when it approved a zoning change that allowed housing to be constructed without parking if it's within 500 feet of a bus or light-rail stop with frequent service. That's defined as an arrival every 20 minutes.
Hales said he envisioned developers building condominium- or townhouse-sized apartments on top of retail stores. He did not expect boxy, four-story buildings packed with studios and one-bedroom apartments.
For almost a decade, his vision was right. But then Portland found itself with an apartment shortage following the condominium boom and ensuing real-estate bust, and developers saw a chance to fill the desperate need.
Hales said he remains a champion of density, a word you hear a lot in Portland, but the city has to make adjustments so that future buildings better fit into the urban fabric.
It is a good thing that we're building up and not out, Hales told The Associated Press. But we also have to be pragmatic in the present day. People still own cars.
The city's Bureau of Planning and Sustainability has proposed that developers of larger apartment buildings those with at least 40 units include at least one parking space for every four units. Hales said he has yet to decide if that's the right target.
Joe Zehnder, Portland's chief planner, said the city is looking for a middle ground that takes some pressure off of streets like Division but does not create so much parking that the city is one day awash in unused spaces.
Car-sharing programs are proliferating and the national trend, especially for younger people, shows a decline in vehicle ownership, he said.
Justin Wood, a developer and associate director of the Home Builders Association of Metro Portland, said Zehnder's idea is a good compromise for a city that wants to limit sprawl, steer people away from driving and have relatively affordable apartments.
According to city estimates, it costs developers $3,000 per space for surface parking, $20,000 per space for structured parking and $55,000 per space for underground parking. Wood notes that many of the planned buildings are on small lots, making it a challenge to install parking spaces.
Wood said he wouldn't like to see a four-story building with no parking rise next to his house. But the only other way the city could handle the newcomers is to embrace the suburban-style growth that makes most Portlanders cringe.
You're not going to stop people from moving to Portland, he said.
City leaders want to see them in neighborhoods with a mix of residential and commercial structures, so people can be a quick walk or bike ride away from restaurants, coffee shops and grocery stores.
A city survey of residents in the parking-free buildings found that 72 percent own cars, but only half that many drive to work. They keep a vehicle for trips across town or weekend getaways.
Ryan McGuire, 30, moved to Portland from St. Paul, Minn., last year and lives in the 50-unit Irvington Garden Apartments. The building in NE Portland has more than 50 bike racks but no parking.
McGuire said he and his girlfriend both have bikes and share one car. As the city survey suggests, McGuire said he keeps a car to go snowboarding and haul stuff.
On-street parking also does not appear to be that difficult to find on Division Street, the epicenter of the apartment boom. Ample spaces were found during three recent visits to the neighborhood, on different days and at different times.
That, however, will likely change when more of the planned apartment buildings reach completion, including the 81-unit building that is the largest project on what has become a trendy stretch of the city. Construction on that building has stopped, at least temporarily, because of an Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals ruling that involves a technicality unrelated to the lack of parking.
Elisabeth Varga, who lives near the building and was one of the people who filed the Appeals Board complaint, emphasized that she and other opponents favor density, as long as it's done responsibly. Parking is just one issue, she said. Traffic congestion is another, and the four-story building is out of scale with the rest of the neighborhood.
People move to Portland for the quality of life, she said. Part of quality of life is being able to access your streets and not be towered over by a monster of a building.
Zehnder, the city planner, said Portland's policy goals of becoming less car-dependent while growing taller instead of wider appear to be working, but he understands why it may be alarming to residents such as Varga.
Now you're seeing it, he said of the density. And it's one thing to think it hypothetically, it's one thing to see it happen and it's another thing entirely to see it happen as much at one time as they're seeing it on Division.