[an error occurred while processing this directive]

New York's mayor shines during adversity, wins praise from critics
Monday, Sept. 17, 2001
 
• Background on Osama bin Laden
• Photos of suspected hijackers

Video:
• Sept. 12: Bush speaks to nation from Cabinet Room
• Sept. 13: Bush warns of 'new kind of war'
• Sept. 14: Bush visits workers at Ground Zero
• Sept. 14: Day of Remembrance at National Cathedral
Evans Caglage / Dallas Morning News
New York Mayor, Rudy Giuliani pauses to talk with reporters enroute to the World Trade Center on Sept. 11, 2001.
By BETH J. HARPAZ
Associated Press Writer

NEW YORK – Mayor Rudolph Giuliani has been quoting Winston Churchill to help New York get through its darkest hour.

Now, even the mayor's usual critics say his steady leadership since the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center has been Giuliani's finest hour.

After barely escaping with his own life from a building adjacent to the twin towers, he gently, calmly informed his fellow New Yorkers that the death toll would be "more than any of us could bear." He lost personal friends and officiated at funerals; he has worked around the clock, holding news conferences in between visits to the disaster site and meetings to coordinate the response; he has pledged to rebuild and prosper; and he even found time to officiate at a wedding, saying, "This is what life is all about."

Many New Yorkers are now wishing they could undo a term-limits law that prevents the lame-duck mayor – who has just three months left in office – from running for office again.

"Ten more years!" shouted a rescue worker Monday as Giuliani toured the site of the World Trade Center disaster.

Giuliani's new admirers include diehard Democrats who never voted for him, activists who have long lambasted him as insensitive to minorities, and people in other countries who may not have known his name a week ago.

Political consultants say Giuliani could run for anything now and win.

Giuliani deflected the acclaim. "What I should do is do the job until Dec. 31, and prepare someone else as the next mayor," he said.

Ordinary New Yorkers disagree.

"I wish he could stay on and that we didn't have term limits," said Linda Yarwood, a Manhattan paralegal. "I would vote for him again. He is a pillar of strength for our community and our nation."

Rachel Biern, who works as an online researcher, did not support the mayor until now.

"I think he's been amazing under crisis," she said. "He was calm and he kept people together. He was just the right balance of sadness and determination. He really does care about New York."

The mayor ran for Senate from New York last year against Hillary Rodham Clinton but dropped out of the race six months before the election amid revelations that he had prostate cancer and a girlfriend. (He is now in the middle of a nasty divorce.)

Nelson Warfield, a Republican political consultant and former press secretary to Bob Dole, predicted that "whoever becomes mayor will beg him to stay on in some role to oversee the rebuilding of the city. But I think Rudy Giuliani goes wherever he wants from here. If he chooses to seek political office, I can't imagine anybody stopping him."

Four Democrats and two Republicans are running for mayor. The primary was supposed to have taken place Sept. 11, the day two hijacked jets crashed into the Trade Center. The primary was rescheduled for Sept. 25.

Former Mayor Ed Koch, a Democrat who wrote a book about Giuliani called "Nasty Man," said the mayor "over the last eight years has often been petty and insensitive. But there's no question he has risen to the occasion here. The challenge of leading the city when it's under attack, comparable to war, has been met."

Koch suggested that Giuliani be kept on as a reconstruction czar.

Asked Monday if he would consider being an anti-terrorism czar, Giuliani said: "I've never been big on czars."

On Sunday, Giuliani presided at a promotion ceremony for the Fire Department to fill its leadership ranks after hundreds of firefighters were lost Tuesday.

He quoted Churchill during the ceremony, saying: "Courage is rightly esteemed the first of human qualities because it's the quality which guarantees all others."

In an interview with Barbara Walters to air Monday night on ABC, Giuliani recommended that people read "about the Battle of Britain and how the people of London lived through the constant daily bombardment by the Nazis. ... They never gave up their spirit, and they figured out how to go about their lives."

Even the Rev. Al Sharpton, a black activist who has persistently accused the mayor of being insensitive to the needs of minorities, admitted Giuliani had "done a good job. I have no criticism."

He was especially impressed that one of the mayor's first announcements to New Yorkers – amid the shock, terror and mourning – was a call for tolerance, given the city's diverse immigrant population and large Muslim community.

"It was a good thing for him to say," Sharpton said. "I was happy to see him set a different tone than he has set in the last eight years."

Randy Mastro, who heads a commission on the City Charter, which bars officials from serving more than two terms, said he has received hundreds of calls and e-mails "asking if there's anything that can be done to see to it that Rudy continues as mayor."

But Mastro said that even as a write-in candidate, Giuliani could not legally serve unless the City Council or the state Legislature changed the term limits law. With Democrats running both bodies, that does not appear likely.

Even overseas, Giuliani has admirers.

"Giuliani is doing a brilliant job and everyone has said that," said Yvonne Hosking, a London secretary. "I find him very compassionate, he really came to the fore."

She said she wouldn't necessarily compare him to Churchill, but added: "I can see a Churchillian attitude."
[an error occurred while processing this directive]