Share this article:
Print

MAX operator fired after boy separated from father

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

by Anne Yeager and KGW.com Staff

Posted on November 25, 2009 at 2:03 PM

Updated Wednesday, Nov 25 at 3:50 PM

******

PORTLAND -- A MAX operator was fired Wednesday after the separation of a father from his 3-year-old son at the Main Street platform last week.

TriMet said the operator ignored four calls on the emergency intercom system on November 16, which created a potential danger.

KGW identified the driver as Paul Cooper.

“This operator’s actions were unacceptable,” TriMet General Manager Fred Hansen said. “They also do not represent our 1,300 operators who everyday deliver quality service to thousands of riders.”

Bailey said that the MAX train's door closed before his son, Aiden, could climb aboard.

Bailey was taking his son to Head Start.  The Green Line was approaching the Main Street Platform when the doors opened.As Aiden stepped out onto the platform, the doors shut, separating the child from his father.

"I frantically tried to push the open button, but they didn’t open, “ Bailey said. 

A Good Samaritan who had been standing on the MAX platform took Aiden by the hand and waited on the bench, according to a statement issued by TriMet on Nov. 20.

Cooper was suspended earlier in the week.

TriMet inspected the intercom system and re-created the incident, determining there was no mechanical malfunction.

In a statment Friday, the Amalgamated Transit Union spokesman Jon Hunt said the agency was too eager to "throw (the) operator under the train.

"Before doing any investigation whatsoever, TriMet managers announce to the press that they intend to discipline the operator of the train.  The question everyone should ask is 'why is TriMet management so quick to point the blame away from themselves and onto the operator?'"

Hunt added that MAX operators and passengers complained about malfunctioning communication equipment on the new trains and the manufacturer about these issues but there has been no resolution.

"TriMet managers knew about this problem even before the Green Line to Clackamas was opened to the public.”

Bailey said he pushed the intercom at least 10 times without response. No one answered, he said.

"I had him in my hand ... when he was exiting he pulled the handicap button, “ Bailey explained. "I frantically tried to push the open button, but they didn’t open."

Bailey said he exited the train at the next stop, crossed, and took the first train heading back toward his son.

The boy waited approximately seven minutes with the Good Samaritan, TriMet said.

"We embraced and I cried for a minute and then I hugged her (the Good Samaritan) and we cried for a minute,” Bailey said.

Once the relief passed Bailey became angry with the operator's response and questioned why the train doors had closed on his son, and why the operator did not answer the intercom calls.

Bailey told KGW Wednesday on he was sad that the firing had to happen, but that TriMet had to set a precedent.

"When this all started, I would have been happy with  personal apology. With Tri-met’s admission, I hope he’ll (the operator) be held accountable in the future," Bailey said.

Did you see this incident - or do you know how to contact the Good Samaritan who helped? Send us an E-mail

The Baileys received family passes for a year and an apology.

Share this article:
Print

To add a comment, please register or login.

Leave your comment
1000 characters remaining

Submit

Remember Please be respectful of others when posting comments. Play nice. IP addresses are logged and can be banned.

HTML is not allowed.

shallowend said on November 20, 2009 at 8:05 AM

If this happened to my child, I would already have my lawyers in motion and the damages would be 10 figures plus. And I hate our modern litigious society. Government agencies are protected from tort claims except in the presence of malice or conduct that would cause a reasonable prudent person to exclaim "Outrageous!". Clearly this is the latter case. I would like to see how long that train was at the platform, because I strongly suspect that the driver was trying to get back on schedule. I can buy either the handicapped ramp not working, or the intercom not working, but the chances of both failing at the same time stretches the bounds of probability.

pschweitzer said on November 20, 2009 at 8:46 AM

The parent of this kid should go to jail for a week for being not aware of what is going on.

wlingren said on November 20, 2009 at 9:19 AM

The same thing happened to me, except I didn't have a child with me - just this week - the door wouldn't open and I missed my stop and the intercom did not work. The problems with the trains are continual - trains not working, heaters not working signage on the trains not working (going to Hillsboro, but will say Ruby Junction or some other eastbound destination, not intercom announcing stops. TriMet needs to pay attention to the trains - we have had our rates increased, and the problems continue, but I notice a lot of new supervisor vehicles out there sitting in parking lots - what happened to more security? I have had to deal with beligerant drunks, fights, filthy language. I ride MAX every day to and from work and maybe see someone checking fares maybe once or twice a month. Supposedly there are cameras on the trains, but know one does anything when there are problems. I pay for my fare and feel it is not asking too much be be comfortable and feel safe.

jenbot72 said on November 20, 2009 at 9:56 AM

That exact same thing happened to me! I was taking my 4 year old twins and 2 year old to the zoo last summer. My twins got out and I started to exit with my 2 year old in the stroller and the doors closed. I het the emergency button but the train started going through the long tunnel by the zoo! I was freaking out! Fortunately my mom, the kids grandmother, got off the train with them. What if I was alone? The Max driver had the nerve to tell me that I need to give them notice BEFORE my stop that I need extra time to get off the train. I couldn't believe it. She acted like it was no big deal. I contacted Trimet and they simply told me they would look into it. The Max driver told me she called security to make sure the kids were okay but it was my mother that had to find security. The never went down looking for them. Now remember the stop we were at was the Zoo. That is below ground. Trimet really needs to figure out why this happens and allow people more time to exit.

lalalu said on November 20, 2009 at 10:03 AM

Aaron is my nephew. He called to tell me of the incident, reliving the horror as he described it to me. He and his wife are extremely good parents to their children and I can only imagine what it was like. God bless that wonderful woman for being there! I hope that this unfortunate incident will wake Tri-Met up to correct the problem. If the driver is not capable of monitoring the cameras and inter-com system then a "spotter" should be on board. Any number of horrible things could happen on the train. Is it unreasonable to expect that what goes on be monitored for the publics safety... I think not!

1micnmoms said on November 20, 2009 at 10:06 AM

Wait a minute people, things happen. The lady who stayed and protected Alden deserves the Portland Good Citizen Award. Thats the good thing that happened...

lalalu said on November 20, 2009 at 10:08 AM

In response to "pschweitzer". Your comment is un-called for. I am guessing you must be impaired in some way! If you paid attention to the video you will see Aarons hand holding Aidens while getting off the train. The door closed on his arm forcing him to let-go. This could have happened to anybody!!

rocky63215 said on November 20, 2009 at 10:53 AM

What is the system that it's in place? It's a machine, a machine is designed to work, but at times will fail. I understand the frustration of the father for both the intercom and the door closing on him. Yet, if you look at the video you can see that the other doors were still open. He panicked! Some question are did he not have a cell phone? I'm pretty sure there was another person in the train that had a cell phone. Meaning they could have called 911 to report what happened and make sure that a trimet police or at least a cop could make sure his child was alright. . Seven minutes is a long time for a child to be left alone, he's lucky that the young woman was around to watch out for his son.

spewie said on November 20, 2009 at 11:00 AM

I see KGW doesn't like people who question them about their racist articles... Si Se Puede!

stephmarie2 said on November 20, 2009 at 11:17 AM

The Dad HAD to let go or the Child could have been pulled. It is unfortunate and I am sure he will be carrying him off in the future.

dodgeram said on November 20, 2009 at 11:54 AM

I would like to buy that lady a coffee and a doughnut for staying with the kid and yes she should get the city award.

god_is_a_lib said on November 20, 2009 at 12:01 PM

I rode max for fun with my by all the time when he was that age (just a few years ago). Kids will always push buttons - literally and figuratively. And there were several occasions when my boy was horsing around getting off the train and daddy had to yank him off the train. I didn't care what people thought about that. I can't imagine many feelings much worse than potentially losing your little boy. And what is with the lack of a functioning emergency system?!! What if someone was stabbed, assualted.. had a heart attack? TRI-MET, I love you - but please get your sh** together!

sugarsgizmo said on November 20, 2009 at 12:07 PM

Thank You, Good Samaritian. I believe there are still Good People out there. This should of not happen. Please Tri-met do explain? How Heart wrenching for this Father, who did everything right and Thank goodness the Little boy wasn't attached to anything or worse. But I know Tri-met will use the excuse of not having enough Funding to Solve the problems of the train, when in fact this should be part of maintence.

rdnblue said on November 20, 2009 at 12:12 PM

Hey, pschweitzer...I think you should spend a week in jail for making inane and immensely ignorant comments on the internet. That declaration holds just as much weight as yours. People DIE from being hit by MAX trains. Kids do stuff like push buttons, but when you push a handicap button, it shouldn't make the doors slam shut. Period. Anyone who has ridden the MAX knows this. When you call on the intercom, the operator has to respond. Period. Trimet has been jacking up rider fees for years and this is what we all get? Seriously? It's nice we have another MAX line that nearly duplicates the streetcar, but stuff has to work or people aren't going to be kept safe.

news_junkie60 said on November 20, 2009 at 1:35 PM

This is driver error, pure and simple. Driver paid no attention to what was going on, around their train. The driver of the train needs retraining. Not everything can be blamed on the "equipment". The dad could have also pulled the emergency lever to stop the train. Luckily the young woman who took care of the young boy stayed with him. Kudos to her. If found, this young woman needs to be commended by the City of Portland for her actions.

jenbot72 said on November 20, 2009 at 3:50 PM

To the person that made the cell phone comment...When it happened to me the max was going through a tunnel so I COULDN'T call anyone on my cell phone. I was in a state of panic the entire time wondering if my kids ran after the train to try to get to me. Even though their grandma was with them they were hysterical thinking I left them. To this day, and it's been I think over a year, they are scared to death to even get in an elevator because they are afraid the doors will close and one of us will not get in. It is frightening for kids. The scary things is that Trimet doesn't do anything to ensure that it doesn't happen.

bob_pdx said on November 20, 2009 at 3:58 PM

I don't know if anyone is still reading all the comments at this point, but I'd like to point out that it is the standard and correct behavior for the door to close when the wheelchair button is pressed. In order for the wheelchair ramp (which is what the button is actually requesting) to safely deploy, the doors must close. Pushing the button causes the doors with the ramp to close, the ramp then deploys, and then the door re-opens. However, what happens after that is troubling -- the train operator should have responded on the intercom (or the intercom should be fixed if it wasn't properly working), and the doors should have sprung back open when blocked by the father's arm. I'm posting this not to excuse the troubling aspects of this situation, but only to point out that some of what happened is not actually a malfunction or incorrect behavior.

bob_pdx said on November 20, 2009 at 4:00 PM

One other note: In the lead-in to the story, the anchor referred to a parent's "worst nightmare". There is no need for this hyperbole. I can think of plenty of nightmares far worse than being momentarily separated from a child in a public place. I'm very glad that this ended well, but we really shouldn't be so terrified of having young children be temporarily unsupervised in public.

emmabailey33 said on November 20, 2009 at 5:37 PM

this was my son and husband! let me clarify a few things, yes Aaron freaked out, and yes he coukd have used his phone, but in a moment like that he wasn't clearly thinking. He was VERY upset and concerned about our son's safety. We are trying to get Trimet to be accountable for the negligence on the part of the operator. He didn't look at the video, mirrors, and he didn't respond to the ER calls. I agree with the thought of what if someone was being killed or hurt. And sorry, but an annual pass to ride the Trimet systrem is not enough of an apology. That is obsured and adding insult to injury!!!! Thank you to the Good Sam from the bottom of my heart. I wish to find you only to tell you that you are the most amazing person ever. Portland needs to give you an award. Thank you Thank you thank you thank you thank you!!!

yamhill354 said on November 20, 2009 at 8:35 PM

To bob_pdx Yes this IS the beginning of a parents worst nightmare. Do you never read or listen to the NEWS. There are constantly little ones coming up missing and later found dead because some freak did unspeakable things to them. Shame on you for making light of this situation! In this case the nightmare had a good ending but it could have so been otherwise. Had it not been for a Guardian Angel many horrible things could have happened to this poor little fellow.

boringdog said on November 20, 2009 at 8:47 PM

First of all let me say that no one is calling this a bad parent however my four year old would not be far enough away from me to get seperated. I have rode Trimet for a long time and the lights start blinking after an audible announcement the doors are closing. The person that wants to sue for six figures over this you are the reason that everything is so expensive why don't you sue your parents for such bad genes.

jfitzpa503 said on November 20, 2009 at 9:06 PM

I'm glad everyone is ok ... However, as a wheelchair user, I would like to add that there are big stickers that state "The doors must close for the ramp deploy". If the boy hit the wheelchaiir button, the doors are designed to close. The dad could have left his arm through the door - the doors are designed to open if something is in the way.

washcomom said on November 20, 2009 at 9:16 PM

I'm wondering why Tri-Met has TWO incidents like this of late. That means that the conductor/operator of the trains is not totally in communication with the rest of the trains. Check the intercom, check the emergency buttons on all cars, check and make sure that the conductor/operator is not in the middle of texting, listening to tunes, or on the phone. Makes me really wonder what is going on when the train is leaving full board and someone is screaming that their child is left on the platform.

rocky63215 said on November 20, 2009 at 9:22 PM

Actually Jenbot it wouldn't matter if you were going through a tunnel, even if there's no service on your cell phone 911 will work.

tmcas said on November 20, 2009 at 9:50 PM

He was taking his little 3 year old to "Head Start"........aka........Child Care.........aka.........SOMEONE ELSE RAISING YOUR KID ! Who knows.......if the little guy was home with his Mommy and not being dropped off to complete strangers....maybe this never would have happened? "Head Start"...........come on, call it what it is! Alas.........another parent who thinks it is ok to have their own flesh and blood with strangers rather than the parent(s). Glad the little kiddo is safe though!

bob_pdx said on November 20, 2009 at 10:48 PM

Dear "yamhill354": I did not "make light" of anything. I made no jokes at the child's or parent's expense. I noted that there were aspects of this incident which were troubling. If you think that little bit of chatter about the facts is making light of the situation, and if you truly think that little ones are "constantly" being found dead, you need to stop watching fright-TV, take a deep breath, and realize that most people are decent. There are risks in the world, and bad things do happen, and we need to be smart and careful... but we need not be fearful and our kids are not in constant danger of abduction and death just because the doors on a train close unexpectedly.

danimomoftwo said on November 21, 2009 at 12:52 AM

I think you who sit on your horse and point fingers at those parents should be ashamed! what right do you have? none! Those people that put their child in the care of others so that they can be a productive part of society are not bad parents! We work to feed those beautiful little mouths and keep them in warm clothes! and those of you who claim that that poor boys father was in the wrong ! you have no right to accuse anyone, have you ever been separated from your child? Can you honestly say that you would be thinking clearly and call 911?as you watch you child get separated from you all you can think is how fast can you get your angel back in your arms...Those faces are what get us up in the morning! So before you start pointing fingers at others you have never met, based on a video you saw on the internet coupled with a story you read, please take time to step into their shoes and think before you run your fingers across your keyboard in judgment!

tmcas said on November 21, 2009 at 8:08 AM

Whatever you say Danimomoftwo............. You just keep dropping your kids off for someone else to raise.......and we will choose door #2! (Having one of the parents stay home with your kiddo) You know what is really ironic about this? Even a Momma ferret wouldn't leave their own little baby with anyone but the mom..........however, with humans, we don't think twice about letting some other people raise your kid.........ALL DAY LONG! Just a little info. for you to think about .............. as you are driving away from your child and letting someone else raise them.

rdziekan said on November 21, 2009 at 9:24 AM

tmcas, do you seriously thing parents put their children in day care because they want to? Especially single mothers? For many families, its the only choice, the only way both parents can work. To make ends meet, many families NEED two incomes. That said, you're not allowing anyone else to raise them, regardless, anymore than you are when your kids are in school. The teachers aren't raising them. The teachers are no more the kids parents than the daycare staff is, and the kids know it. You choose your door #2, its not an option for many of us. Not those of us who are struggling financially to pay our bills on time and keep a roof over our families heads, and who are still unsure if we'll be able to afford it all. Of this entire story, you choose to attack the family for putting their kid in daycare? Get off your high horse and realize that given the choice, of course we'd rather be with our kids all day.

kebler823 said on November 21, 2009 at 11:21 AM

Can anyone imagine if the kid was on a leash!

lauriannni said on November 21, 2009 at 1:41 PM

Hopefully this incident, as well as others like i,t will put a safety net in place that is truly efficient. Things like this can happen so quickly, and the parents in this case sound like excellent parents. I think it is very unreasonable and destructive to make any comments to the contrary. This was obviously an accident. I am so glad there was a kind and considerate woman there who was able to help them. May blessings be hers, as well as the family who endured this scare.

pdxmaxlady said on November 21, 2009 at 2:23 PM

First let me say Thank You to the very nice lady who took care of the child. I am glad he is ok. A lot of things went wrong. What the train operator saw if they could see anything much was a child pushed the ramp request as they got off the train and a woman was with the child. It is unfortunate the intercom did not work or the dad did not know how it works? People who ride the train need to know some basics 1 the doors have a sensitive edge and will reopen if you leave your arm in them just give it a minute you don't need to push it. 2 The intercom on the passenger emergency is a one way mice. If the operator is pushing the button to talk they can't hear. It's not like a telephone you have to wait. The operator also does not know where you are on the train. Give front or rear car and door number. p3 Dad could have pulled the bright red lever next to the door. I don't recommend this, but the train would stop and the door would open although it may be a long way to the ground.

nonpartisan said on November 21, 2009 at 2:44 PM

It dawned on me that what's being described here is actually correct operation of the door. When the MAX operator is ready to drive off, he/she closes the doors. In the process, it deactivates the yellow and blue buttons. This is by design; otherwise, people would be able to run up at the very last second and press the door button. The train would never be able to get going!! I can't explain why the operator didn't answer the emergency call button. But turning the buttons off is normal operation so that the train can get going. Watch the buttons when you're on the train -- as the doors are getting ready to close, the green/red rings around the yellow and blue buttons will turn off so that they're not operational. That is by design. It doesn't help in a situation like this, but during normal daily operation, an incident like this doesn't happen.

emmabailey33 said on November 21, 2009 at 3:37 PM

TO TMCAS, First of all, thanks for your imput on the situation, but let me clue you in on something...Head Start i s a pre-school program that lasts for 3 hours a day. As for "Mommy", I work, and daddy is the stay at home parent. Do you have children? If so how many? I think that it is not only ingnorant, but ridiculous that you would even make those UNEDUCATED comments! Why is it so terrible that my son goes to school? We have 3 children, and my husband is at home EVERY DAY with them. He is not sent to daycare, it is SCHOOL. SO SHUT UP!!! And by the way, so what if it was day care? Some people need to use daycare to work and feed their children. Would you prefer that people stay at home and abuse the welfare system?

danimomoftwo said on November 21, 2009 at 4:29 PM

Well stated emmabailey33! kudos to you for trying give your child all that you can! We as parents all want the best for our children and work hard to provide such. tmcas is not taking in to account anything except the blurb she saw/read and judging your life accordingly....WE ALL are so HAPPY that this ended with your sweetpea safe!

danzhanzen said on November 21, 2009 at 5:13 PM

As a parent I find it rediculous that some people use an incident like this to spew out church lady style self-righteousness to the parents. The fact that the kids go to head start has zero to do with a trimet door shutting suddenly. It could have happened anywhere at any time. I am very happy that Orianne was right there because the child could have tried to grab the train or run after it and been seriosly injured or worse. At best he would have suffered the trauma of being all alone in that situation had no one been there. The child could not have been in better hands. Perhaps she is a gardian angel.

oregonpaul said on November 21, 2009 at 5:26 PM

To the Good Samaritan, You are truly a great lady, I thank you for looking out for Aiden. To the Parents of Aiden, You have Angels looking out for your child. To all those who are blaming parents: What will you do if something like this happens to your child when you are separated? Don't say it "wont" happen, because YOU never know. So give the parents a break. I am very happy that we have people who actually care about someone other than themselves. To Trimet, quit paying upper management big bucks!!! Use money to make sure the system works. You cant make money if your systems aren't working right, cause you will spend more money in lawsuits.

nguha28 said on November 21, 2009 at 5:51 PM

I'm sure that it was a terrifying experience. I don't think tri-met nor the train operator is responsible. The father should be held accountable for his sons safety. He lucked out there was someone nice enough to help the child in this situation. It's no ones fault except the fathers for not keeping a watchful eye over his son.

blkbry said on November 21, 2009 at 6:47 PM

I would like the spelling corrected in the story from "He boy" the The boy.

blkbry said on November 21, 2009 at 6:47 PM

to

corporatemom said on November 21, 2009 at 9:59 PM

Hold the child's hand and step out with him. Must have been scary for the dad & little boy. Thank you to the nice lady. Trimet - HELLLOOOOOO - please with children and those that are handycap use your services. Please be more observant of who is on your vehicle.

nwskeptic said on November 21, 2009 at 10:23 PM

Emma - I am SO glad your son is ok - When I saw that video, I could see the same thing happening to any of us (I have a 3 year old child too) - I can't believe the harshness of some of these comments. I do believe most people are decent, thankfully there was a woman there who cared and stayed with the child. Anyway, don't waste your time dealing with the morons that have nothing better to do than to try to get a reaction.

danzhanzen said on November 21, 2009 at 11:32 PM

The father seems like an attentive and good dad. He was taking his kid to school on the max, how many dads are out doing that everyday. For anyone to be saying that he did anything wrong is ridiculous. The door slammed shut while they were walking and they couldn't get it back open. Things happen and I'm sure Trimet will fix this issue. Obviously they released the video. Thank God Orianne was standing there, you couldn't ask for a better person and she did a wonderful job taking charge of the situation and having Aiden to sit down and wait for his dad.

topazgirl said on November 23, 2009 at 3:41 PM

I am so glad this child is safe!! And the poor father...!! Children are so fast at times, and they can dart in a second!! The part that REALLY frightens me is the the mechanism of the door!! What if the child had gotten the sleeve of his jacket, or the hood of his hoody caught in this door as it closed, and the child had been dragged to the next stop?!! Horrifying!! There needs to be something done immediately about the way the door system works! This could be LIFE threatening!!...

elorentzen said on November 23, 2009 at 3:56 PM

Sounds like damage control by TRIMET. Why would the driver be in trouble if it was equipment trouble? And why would they give the family a free annual pass on public money? ...........Unless it was damage control

robert57 said on November 23, 2009 at 5:43 PM

Never trust TRIMET

news_junkie60 said on November 23, 2009 at 6:30 PM

The fact that the train driver pushed the "Door CLOSE", instead of allowing the ramp to come out, proves to me that the driver of the train was inattentive of what was going on. He/she wanted to get away and on to the next station. This is not customer service. As for Tri-Met giving the family "Free Family passes for a yr", that's such a slap in the face. It's an insult to everyone involved. Why not honor the young woman who stayed with the child with a pass for life!!! Tri-Met really needs to rethink it's mission statement. "We're here to get you there" aint really ringing true, now is it?

anonany said on November 23, 2009 at 7:29 PM

Wait...if the handicapped button closes the door to put the ramp out for a wheelchair and then reopens, the train left the station without the ramp coming out or the door reopening. There wasn't even enough time for that to occur or a person in a wheelchair to get off the train. Maybe that is how it's supposed to work but it wouldn't have let a handicapped person off either. Not only that, who is going to leave their arm in a closing door that may or may not stop. A small child is not fine by themselves for 7 minutes in public. While I do not think that horrible things always happen, there are a lot of serious things that could have happened to that child in 7 minutes. Had the lady not been there, he could have ended up walking off and getting hit by a car, on the tracks for the next train to find, tried to run after his dad and gotten hurt. A 3 year old does not have the skills to be able to make "safe" decisions.

anonany said on November 23, 2009 at 7:34 PM

cont... People would be all over a parent for leaving their 3 year old alone in public for 7 minutes. This man was being a responsible parent. He was holding his hand not just letting the boy run wild. It seems to me that the train driver did several things wrong. Being in a hurry is not an excuse to endanger people. If there are cams didn't he see the man's arm hanging out or the fact that it was being pulled away from a child. I would think the train would have something that would notify the driver that the wheelchair button had been pressed so they would wait longer and specifically check the cams to make sure everyone was on fully prior to proceeding on the route.

steffiney said on November 23, 2009 at 8:19 PM

TMCAS-seriously, your comment isn't even worth responding to. You disgust me! This exact situation happened to my sister and my nephew when he was 2 years old, but it was on a Trimet bus. The doors closed after my nephew was lead down the stairs and my sister had no other choice but to let go of my nephews hand on a very busy street, leaving a 2 year old all alone. She was screaming to the driver along with everyone else on the bus to stop and the driver wouldn't stop. I'm starting to think they intentionally ignore passengers. Things turned out fine in my family's situation and I'm so glad things turned out great in this situation. I can't even imagine what that father was going thru during those 7 minutes. Thank God for that wonderful woman!

washcomom said on November 23, 2009 at 8:28 PM

Partial blame? REALLY??? For separating the two? Look closely. The dad couldn't even get out the door as he was stunned by the rapid closure. What was the outcome of the disciplinary hearing/suspension - with or without pay? What was the driver doing at the time to disregard the intercom? And where is the PUBLIC APOLOGY from Tri-Met as well as the operator? The passes are a drop in the bucket for the angst this trauma caused in this family's life. Tri-Met has a lot of PR work it needs to do with the public to put themselves back in a good light. Thank goodness Good Samaritans come in the form of an angelic person like the lady who stayed with the boy. Good luck to the Baileys! And the Good Samaritan.

dodgeram said on November 23, 2009 at 9:10 PM

The last line in the story "The Baileys received family passes for a year and an apology for the series of "malfunctions." A SERIES OF MALFUNCTIONS I want to know what in the H##L IS TRI-MESS SMOKING AND DRINKING!!!!! The driver ignored the intercom AND overriden the ramp call like a few others said what if there was some one in a chair or with a walker HUMMMM!!!!

nwskeptic said on November 23, 2009 at 9:26 PM

"partially responsible" - what a joke. The driver is completely responsible for ignoring the intercom. They should be FIRED

ladidadi said on November 23, 2009 at 10:53 PM

I CANT BELIEVE IT!ALL THESE COMMENTS SHOWS HOW MANY OF YOU DONT RIDE THE MAX ! HOW SAD. This is OF COURSE NOT the the Max conductors fault! As an ex 7 day a week max riders for years , I can say I know the Issues trimet hasbut this is NOT IT!. When the kid pressed the buttom from the inside, the Handicapped Ramp was ACTIVATED. When this happens the DOORS Close FIRST then Ramp comes OUT, and Then Doors ReOPEN,But when the dad freaked out he or the lady outside pressed the Handicapped buttom again which TOLD the system the Ramp wasnt needed anymore So the Doors Just Stayed close. The Conductor looks to the sides , Sees a kid and a mom standing next to the Platform and Pulls AWAY! I'm most likely sure this exact incident has happened before. The Problem Trimet has is when It Makes Psychially Handicapped Elderly Men and Women Run after a Bus That pulls away from Its Bus stop location Earlier than schedule , and the Drivers watches that Handicapped person for seconds without doing a thing!

oregon5 said on November 24, 2009 at 12:11 AM

I am happy that this story had a happy ending. But people here in Portland do NOT respect the TriMet drivers of buses or of Max! I have rode both and I am ashamed of some of the people that I have seen get on and off. Portlanders are lucky and should be more appreciative of the public transportation. Not all large cities have public transport. So, for the person that would've had a lawyer called already - "GET A LIFE!" Not everything that goes bad with TriMet is NOT TriMets fault. May be some people need to look in the mirror.

ocdave67 said on November 24, 2009 at 7:09 AM

Another issue that has not been discussed is the fact that teens and other young adults frequently press these emergency buttons for "kicks". You can not reasonably expect a driver to stop the train and check out the circumstances of every "prank" that riders pull do you?. TriMet is used by respectable citizens, however that class is the minority. TriMet vehicles often carry the "losers" of society. The people with DUI's, people who can not afford a car for their drug habit etc.. If I was a driver for this company my goal would be to get from stop to stop on schedule and hope I don't get shot in the process. Crime statistics near max and bus stops clearly prove my point above.I would NEVER allow a member of my family to ride on such a "high risk" form or transportation.

adamg said on November 24, 2009 at 7:12 AM

I use trimet daily, i think the driver should be left alone, these drivers have so much to deal with to keep people safe, i've heard people using the intercom to ask directions, ask the driver for money, or other nonsense. When I ride i have everything with me as i enter or exit, if i'm riding with someone we exit/enter as soon as the doors open/close. If you've got a 3 year old son, you either carry him on or hold his hand when boarding/exiting. This is a minor parenting mistake not worthy of the media attention. This trimet operator should be left alone.

shallowend said on November 24, 2009 at 8:34 AM

The operator should be fired, period. Ignoring the intercom is unacceptable regardless of how many teens use it for no reason. I ride MAX every day, and I have seen heart attacks, domestic violence, seizures, and other life-threatening situations occur on the trains. If a heart attack had occurred and the operator ignored the intercom resulting an a death, it would set up Trimet (read THE TAXPAYERS) for a multi-million dollar forced payout. As for "cancelling" the ramp, according to the report the Driver OVERRODE the ramp, which would be a disabled persons ticket to million dollar lawsuit heaven. This isn't about malfunctions or parenting, it's about a driver who simply didn't care.

nwskeptic said on November 24, 2009 at 8:45 AM

Looks like other drivers are starting to post here. adamg - the parent WAS holding the child's hand exiting - watch the video. Your argument is garbage - it's like saying people call 911 to report they got the wrong item at McDonalds - yeah, that happens, but people call with emergencies too. At a minimum, all the drivers need to be retrained, because this is something that should have stopped the train. This isn't a parenting mistake, it is a trimet driver that put a child at serious risk by not doing their job.

elbajohombre said on November 24, 2009 at 11:24 AM

I think it was just an unfortunate series of events that turned out okay thank God. Ladidadi, you are on the money, when I saw the video I imagined what the train operator could have seen in the mirror/outside camera, it looked after the door closed like a little boy was outside the train standing right next to his mother, she was right there like one second later (the Guardian Angel).....thank God she was there, but yeah that could easily have looked like everything was normal. Let's just chalk this up to something that happened, no one's fault. I don't think there is anything positive or constructive about hurting the train operator's livelihood (unless there was a pattern of some sort) and I don't think this should be an opportunity for a big payday, S&*t happens sometimes, that's all.

chrissy923 said on November 24, 2009 at 11:52 AM

When does a parent have to take responsibility for their own children. Being a single parent, I would not have let my young child out of my hands or arms. I agree MAX is not always suitable and is broke down quite a bit but we still have to hold ourselves accountable.

nwskeptic said on November 25, 2009 at 2:29 PM

He was holding the child's hand exiting the train. The door closed quickly - with a door closing, the reflex response will be to move your hand out of the way - it's easy to say otherwise sitting in front of your computer, but when it is unexpected, most people will do that without thinking. This is NOT a parenting issue. The issue was the driver did NOT answer an intercom call - and if ten were made, one would think that would be an emergency that needs to be addressed. I am glad to see Trimet terminated this employee. They still need to retrain the rest.

thomtra123 said on November 25, 2009 at 3:19 PM

Well, it still looks like we don't know the true facts. Mgmt says one thing, the union another and both seem to have documentation to support their respective views. Is the operator really to blame or is he being terminated as a political gesture to appease those involved and the public? Perhaps a real concise independent review and investigation is called for.

carlitosway said on November 25, 2009 at 4:48 PM

Good riddance Paul Cooper. You can wait in line for your Turkey Dinner down on Burnside. I heard that you shut your window on the guy, after he voiced complaints about the intercom not working. Then you drove away, leaving him there. Justice was done.

carlitosway said on November 25, 2009 at 4:58 PM

pschweitzer, where in the heck do total morons like you come from? Go away, go back to where you came from. The guy was holding the kids hand, the door closed on his arm. pschweitzer, pull it out of the nether regions and go home.

macsayswhat said on November 25, 2009 at 5:46 PM

What I wonder about is the father says he tried using the intercom atleast 10 times. The ride was only 3 minutes (one way approximately maybe less) . I wonder if he ever actually let go of the button? But what I really wonder is, even if the driver did answer. What would have been different? You can't just stop a train and go back. You cant stop and let a passenger off in the middle of the track. At best the driver might have been able to call trimet security to go to the platform and wait with the boy for the father to return. The father was seperated from his son for 7 minutes.. kids are lost in malls for longer than that. Scary yes. Worth firing the train operator over? probably not, since 7 minutes was probably the shortest amount of time possible. If the driver had stopped the train im sure it would have been more like a half hour for the father to get back.

topazgirl said on November 25, 2009 at 5:55 PM

It is always sad when someone loses their job, especially in this job market!... But there comes a time when each employee needs to recognize job burn-out, and leave for another job...especially when the safety of others is in their hands!! We are all human and make mistakes, but this mistake could have been life threatening...Most of us have lost jobs that, by all rights, we should have left long before...but it's ALWAYS a good thing when we reach burn-out, to move on down the road however that change is made to happen!....

washcomom said on November 25, 2009 at 6:02 PM

Hallelujuah! There is a God in Portland! Finally - something done RIGHT! Tri-met has actually FIRED the operator. I bet there is more to the story about what the operator was doing vs. what is being released at this time. Whatever the case - look at this VERY closely. It bodes well to do the next right thing - answering the intercom, helping out a fellow being, putting down your cell phones and drive.

cybersleuth said on November 25, 2009 at 6:05 PM

I can't help but think, "That's a man for you", holding the child by the hand. No way would I hold hands in such a potentially dangerous situation where a train is involved. A mother would more likely hold a 3-year old child in her arms on a train platform. I wonder if the man was on a cell phone. Just saying.

bsassy said on November 25, 2009 at 7:42 PM

ditto to elbajohombre's comments. One can blame the parent of the boy or the operator of the train. The driver doesn't deserve to be fired because he didn't answer an intercom. It's not an "emergency" intercom if people use it to ask questions, teens can play with it, etc. If Trimet wants it to be an "emergency" intercom, they need to make it so people can't casually use it. The parent could have blocked the door from shutting if he understood the door system ( a body language person should examine video, its not just about his arm), but it is understandable that he "panicked" or probably thought it would open back up. When the child is with an adult, the child does not appear "stranded." From above comments, I now know why courts can't go strictly on "eye witness accounts."

knave said on November 25, 2009 at 10:38 PM

We know the operator Paul, he is a fine fellow. "FIRED" is a relative term. Remember Portland Police Bureau firings? Done with much outcry and fanfare. Once the furor has died down, the "fired" employee is quietly reinstated with back pay and full seniority as a result of union/mgmt. arbitration. Such will be the outcome of this situation.

axxed said on November 26, 2009 at 1:15 AM

TMCAS just wants attention and likes to stir the pot. Ignore it, it's irrelevant as I'm sure TMCAS is in life. With that said, the driver is definitely to blame on this. They tested the system to see if it worked. It did. S**t-can the driver. Also, continue with litigation. Tri-met is responsible for the actions of it's employees who they charge with the responsibility of maintaining the safety and wellbeing of fare paying passengers while using the system.

spewie said on November 26, 2009 at 7:26 AM

Sadly Anne and the KGW staff don't want you to know how dangerous it is to ride MAX. I ride the crime-line five days a week and believe me... oops, if I go any further my post might get yanked again. Si se Puede!

jalek said on November 26, 2009 at 10:05 AM

How often has a "driver" really done anything? A central monitoring station with cameras at each door and station with remote control and answering the intercoms might be less expensive and more effective than having people riding the trains back and forth. Tri-Met doesn't really HAVE to spend every dime it can milk from taxpayers. Cameras on the train might also help with identifying criminals, since the presence of the driver doesn't seem to deter anything.

pyroclastic said on November 26, 2009 at 3:57 PM

Is this where I post my birthday picture?

tmk20094 said on November 26, 2009 at 4:27 PM

Glad the Max operator was fired. With Oregon's high unemployment rate, I'm sure a better replacement can be found.

classygirl said on November 27, 2009 at 10:06 AM

The dad and the good lady who came to the little boy's side both deserve a metal. I think anybody would pull their arm back, not only for their own safety, but also for the little boys safety. He could have been hurt otherwise. No parent likes to leave their child in harm's way. None of us really know how we will react when something like this happens. Thank God all turned out good. Be big about it and give Dad a break, he did what he had to do and didn't waste any time getting back to the boy. People seem to forget that important detail. 7 minutes is not a long time, but must have seemed like an eternity to both the dad and the boy. Kudos to the lady, she deserves a metal, big time! By the way, there is nothing wrong with your kids going to daycare. Isn't that better than leaving them alone? You do realize it is illegal to leave kids home alone, don't you?? Sure doesn't sound like a lot of you know that. Dad did the right thing, so did the lady. So drop it already!!